Who Is John Dutton's Grandfather? '1923' Family Tree Explained!

Is the Dutton family tree more tangled than the Montana landscape they inhabit? The burning question of whether Spencer Dutton is indeed John Dutton III's grandfather has ignited fervent debates among Yellowstone enthusiasts, fueled by the twists and turns of the prequel series, 1923.

The Dutton saga, a sprawling epic of land, legacy, and blood, has captivated audiences with its intricate family dynamics and the relentless struggle to maintain their empire. Central to this drama is the lineage of John Dutton III, played by Kevin Costner in Yellowstone, and the identity of his grandfather has become a subject of intense speculation, particularly in light of the events unfolding in 1923. The series introduces us to James and Margaret Dutton, who have two other children, Elsa and John Dutton Sr. John Dutton Sr., with his wife Emma, has one child, Jack, before his untimely death. This is where the Dutton family tree becomes more like a dense thicket. The narrative has intentionally obscured whether Spencer or Jack is the father of John Dutton II, and consequently, the grandfather of John Dutton III.

Conflicting narratives within the Yellowstone universe have only deepened the mystery. On one hand, some assert that Spencer Dutton is definitively John Duttons grandfather, pointing to the season 2 finale of 1923, where Spencer's wife, Alexandra, gives birth to John Dutton II, also known as John Dutton Jr. This aligns with the possibility that Spencer would raise Jack Dutton's child as his own, further solidifying his role as the grandfather John Dutton III alludes to in season 4. Proponents of this theory suggest that Spencer is indeed John Dutton III's grandfather, or at least the one whose stories have been passed down through generations. The imdb page lists a character as \u201cspencer 1969,\u201d confirming that spencer dutton not only survives the events of 1923, but also plays a crucial role in the future. This development suggests that spencer may even be the grandfather of john dutton, tying together multiple generations of the dutton family.

• March 30 Aries Personality Compatibility More Zodiac Guide
• Bethany Hamilton Life Shark Attack Husband Adam Dirks

However, this theory is not without its detractors. Critics argue that the generational timeline simply doesn't support Spencer being John's grandfather. They emphasize that the Dutton ranch is described as a 7th-generation operation, with the current John being a 5th-generation Montana rancher whose family arrived six years before Montana achieved statehood. Given that Spencer is a 2nd-generation Montana Dutton, any child he fathers would be a 3rd-generation Dutton, while John's father must be a 4th-generation Dutton. This discrepancy casts doubt on Spencer's direct lineage to John Dutton III.

Adding to the complexity is the existence of Jack Dutton, the son of John Dutton Sr. and Emma. The series has intentionally left open the possibility that Jack, not Spencer, is John Dutton's grandfather. Some viewers believe that events in episode 6 suggest that Costner's John Dutton was indeed referring to his mother's father when discussing his grandfather. This would mean that Jack Dutton is the key to unlocking the Dutton family history. In 1923 season 2, the last two surviving family members that could feasibly serve as John Dutton's grandparents are spencer dutton and jack dutton.

The implications of either Spencer or Jack being John Dutton's grandfather are significant, especially concerning the future of the Yellowstone ranch. The promise given to James Dutton in 1883 was that his family would be allowed to settle on the land for seven generations. If Jack is the grandfather of John III, then Tate, John's grandson, would be the seventh generation and the last of the Dutton family to live on their land. Conversely, if Spencer is the grandfather, that makes Tate only the sixth generation, suggesting that the Dutton legacy on the Yellowstone ranch may continue beyond Tate's lifetime. Spencer dutton is the younger son of james (tim mcgraw) and margaret dutton (faith hill) from the 1883 series.

• Anna Beth Goodman John Goodmans Wife Life And Their Love Story
• Justin Hailey From Teen Meeting To Baby Bliss

The ambiguity surrounding John Dutton's grandfather allows for multiple interpretations and fuels ongoing discussions among fans. Taylor Sheridan, the mastermind behind the Yellowstone universe, has masterfully kept the audience guessing, leaving breadcrumbs and red herrings to keep the mystery alive. The series finale of 1923 promises to shed more light on this crucial aspect of the Dutton family tree, but whether it will provide a definitive answer or further complicate matters remains to be seen. The storyline had not revealed if spencer or jack is the father of john dutton ii and therefore the grandfather of john dutton iii (kevin costner's yellowstone character.

Spencer Dutton, portrayed by Brandon Sklenar, is the second son of James and Margaret Dutton, born after the family settled in Montana. He is also the brother of John Dutton Sr., who was killed in 1923. Spencer marries Alexandra and has a son with her, who may become the father of John Dutton III. He served in World War I and is depicted as a skilled hunter and adventurer. The second son of james and margaret dutton, spencer was born some time after the family settled in montana. He would go on to become the father of john dutton iii, and grandfather to lee. Spencer dutton (brandon sklenar) is the son of james dutton, the brother of john dutton i, and the father of john dutton ii. He marries alexandra and has a son with her, who becomes the father of john dutton iii, the protagonist of yellowstone.

The 1923 storyline follows Spencer's journey as he navigates the challenges of the early 20th century, including economic hardship, drought, and the looming threat of land developers. His relationship with Alexandra adds another layer of complexity to his character, as they face cultural differences and the perils of their environment together. It is unclear if john dutton iii is a direct descendant of spencer or not. Spencer cannot be john's grandfather, the generations don't fit. We have been told the ranch is a 7th gen ranch and that the current john is a 5th gen montana rancher whose family was here 6 years before montana was a state. Spencer is a 2nd gen montana dutton. Any child spencer has will be a 3rd gen dutton while john's father has to be a 4th.

The question of who John Dutton III's grandfather is has significant ramifications for the entire Yellowstone franchise. It affects the Dutton family's claim to the land, the generational dynamics, and the ultimate fate of the Yellowstone ranch. With each episode of 1923, new clues and theories emerge, keeping fans engaged and eager to unravel the mystery of the Dutton family tree. The second john in the family, he would go on to become the father of john dutton iii, and grandfather to lee, jamie, beth, and kayce dutton.

Whether it's Spencer Dutton, the war-torn adventurer, or Jack Dutton, the loyal son of Montana, the identity of John Dutton's grandfather is a puzzle that continues to captivate and intrigue viewers. As the 1923 series progresses, the truth behind the Dutton family history will undoubtedly be revealed, shaping the future of the Yellowstone saga for generations to come. The 1923 family tree hints that spencer and alex will become the parents of john dutton's father. See our full dutton family tree graphic to learn more about how the duttons are related.

Some fans feel like there was a huge mess up in this finale, given that it makes john dutton iii only a fourth. Appearing as an old man in yellowstone flashbacks, john dutton ii is the father of john iii (kevin costner) and spencer\u2019s son. The 1923 season 2 finale revealed that alex gives birth to a. The war for the yellowstone ignites in 1923 season 2's finale, and it's a bloodbath that results in casualties for the duttons and their enemies.

Portrayed by brendan skelnar, spencer is the last living child of james dutton and the younger brother of the late john sr. In season 1 of 1923, spencer married julia schlaepfer's alexandra dutton, a british duchess seeking an escape from her droll life in england. With jack dutton's tragic death in the penultimate episode, spencer dutton remained the strongest contender to become john iii's grandfather. However, confusion still remained as jack's wife, elizabeth, was pregnant. If spencer is john ii\u2019s father, that would make him john iii\u2019s grandfather. If jack is john ii\u2019s father, that would make john, sr.

Either jack or spencer is john's grandfather, and one of them will eventually lose their leg. In yellowstone season 4, jimmy tells john dutton that his fingertips hurt even though he can't. The 1923 family tree suggests spencer and alex will become the parents of john dutton's father. He stays close to the ranch, helping jacob and cara build the family empire. Played by brandon sklenar, spencer\u2019s adventures are a key plotline in 1923. Brandon sklenar casts doubt on spencer dutton's john family tree claims paramount+.

Coming into 1923, many wanted to know which characters were the grandparents of kevin costner's john dutton. John's father, john dutton ii, was seen multiple times in yellowstone through flashbacks, but his parents were never revealed. A key detail on the show\u2019s imdb page lists a character as \u201cspencer 1969,\u201d confirming that spencer dutton not only survives the events of 1923, but also plays a crucial role in the future. This development suggests that spencer may even be the grandfather of john dutton, tying together multiple generations of the dutton family. He is also the sibling of john dutton sr (james badge dale), who met his end in an earlier episode. 1923 star brandon sklenar, who plays spencer dutton, many fans believe the show confirmed in the final episode that spencer dutton was the grandfather of john dutton iii. Since taylor sheridan hasn\u2019t been the best in continuity, fans feel like there was a huge mess up in this finale, given that it makes john dutton iii only a fourth.

The finale answers the great dutton mystery. Spencer is john dutton\u2019s (kevin costner) grandfather. It is unclear if john dutton iii is a direct descendant of spencer or not. Why did the duttons need to wait for spencer to get back to defend the ranch from whitfield? What is going to happen to alex and spencer\u2019s baby\u2014who will become john dutton, grandfather to. There are two different ways to interpret spencer dutton's time jump in 1923 season 2's finale, and either scenario has massive ramifications. 1923 shocks audiences with its latest episode, which brutally kills off a major character without warning. What does his death mean for the finale?

Yes, spencer dutton is john dutton\u2019s grandfather in 1923 season 2. In the 1923 season 2 finale, spencer\u2019s wife, alexandra (alex), gives birth to john dutton ii \u2014 also known as john dutton jr. He is also the sibling of john dutton sr (james badge dale), who met his end in an earlier episode. Portrayed by brendan skelnar, spencer is the last living child of james dutton and the younger brother of the late john sr. In season 1 of 1923, spencer married julia schlaepfer's alexandra dutton, a british duchess seeking an escape from her droll life in england.

With jack dutton's tragic death in the penultimate episode, spencer dutton remained the strongest contender to become john iii's grandfather. However, confusion still remained as jack's wife, elizabeth, was pregnant. If spencer is john ii\u2019s father, that would make him john iii\u2019s grandfather. If jack is john ii\u2019s father, that would make john, sr. In 1923 season 2, the last two surviving family members that could feasibly serve as john dutton's grandparents are spencer dutton (brandon sklenar) and jack dutton (darren mann). Either he or his brother john sr will have a child who will turn out to. Appearing as an old man in yellowstone flashbacks, john dutton ii is the father of john iii (kevin costner) and spencer\u2019s son.

Spencer dutton is the younger son of james (tim mcgraw) and margaret dutton (faith hill) from the 1883 series. He is also the younger brother of john dutton sr (james badge dale). Either jack or spencer is john's grandfather, and one of them will eventually lose their leg. In yellowstone season 4, jimmy tells john dutton that his fingertips hurt even though he can't. Spencer cannot be john's grandfather, the generations don't fit. We have been told the ranch is a 7th gen ranch and that the current john is a 5th gen montana rancher whose family was here 6 years before montana was a state. Spencer is a 2nd gen montana dutton. Any child spencer has will be a 3rd gen dutton while john's father has to be a 4th.

The 1923 family tree suggests spencer and alex will become the parents of john dutton's father. Spencer is the younger son of james (tim mcgraw) and margaret dutton (faith hill) from the. He stays close to the ranch, helping jacob and cara build the family empire. Played by brandon sklenar, spencer\u2019s adventures are a key plotline in 1923. Brandon sklenar casts doubt on spencer dutton's john family tree claims paramount+.

Coming into 1923, many wanted to know which characters were the grandparents of kevin costner's john dutton. John's father, john dutton ii, was seen multiple times in yellowstone through flashbacks, but his parents were never revealed. A key detail on the show\u2019s imdb page lists a character as \u201cspencer 1969,\u201d confirming that spencer dutton not only survives the events of 1923, but also plays a crucial role in the future. This development suggests that spencer may even be the grandfather of john dutton, tying together multiple generations of the dutton family. He is also the sibling of john dutton sr (james badge dale), who met his end in an earlier episode.

1923 star brandon sklenar, who plays spencer dutton, many fans believe the show confirmed in the final episode that spencer dutton was the grandfather of john dutton iii. Since taylor sheridan hasn\u2019t been the best in continuity, fans feel like there was a huge mess up in this finale, given that it makes john dutton iii only a fourth. In 1923 season 2, the last two surviving family members that could feasibly serve as john dutton's grandparents are spencer dutton (brandon sklenar) and jack dutton (darren mann). The finale answers the great dutton mystery. Spencer is john dutton\u2019s (kevin costner) grandfather. It is unclear if john dutton iii is a direct descendant of spencer or not.

See our full dutton family tree graphic to learn more about how the duttons are related. The 1923 family tree hints that spencer and alex will become the parents of john dutton's father. Spencer is the younger son of james (tim mcgraw) and margaret dutton (faith hill) from the 1883 series. Why did the duttons need to wait for spencer to get back to defend the ranch from whitfield? What is going to happen to alex and spencer\u2019s baby\u2014who will become john dutton, grandfather to. There are two different ways to interpret spencer dutton's time jump in 1923 season 2's finale, and either scenario has massive ramifications. 1923 shocks audiences with its latest episode, which brutally kills off a major character without warning. What does his death mean for the finale?

The war for the yellowstone ignites in 1923 season 2's finale, and it's a bloodbath that results in casualties for the duttons and their enemies. The second john in the family, he would go on to become the father of john dutton iii, and grandfather to lee, jamie, beth, and kayce dutton. Yes, spencer dutton is john dutton\u2019s grandfather in 1923 season 2. In the 1923 season 2 finale, spencer\u2019s wife, alexandra (alex), gives birth to john dutton ii \u2014 also known as john dutton jr. He is also the sibling of john dutton sr (james badge dale), who met his end in an earlier episode. Portrayed by brendan skelnar, spencer is the last living child of james dutton and the younger brother of the late john sr.

In season 1 of 1923, spencer married julia schlaepfer's alexandra dutton, a british duchess seeking an escape from her droll life in england. With jack dutton's tragic death in the penultimate episode, spencer dutton remained the strongest contender to become john iii's grandfather. However, confusion still remained as jack's wife, elizabeth, was pregnant. If spencer is john ii\u2019s father, that would make him john iii\u2019s grandfather. If jack is john ii\u2019s father, that would make john, sr. In 1923 season 2, the last two surviving family members that could feasibly serve as john dutton's grandparents are spencer dutton (brandon sklenar) and jack dutton (darren mann).

Either he or his brother john sr will have a child who will turn out to. Appearing as an old man in yellowstone flashbacks, john dutton ii is the father of john iii (kevin costner) and spencer\u2019s son. The 1923 season 2 finale revealed that alex gives birth to a. Spencer dutton is the younger son of james (tim mcgraw) and margaret dutton (faith hill) from the 1883 series. He is also the younger brother of john dutton sr (james badge dale). Either jack or spencer is john's grandfather, and one of them will eventually lose their leg. In yellowstone season 4, jimmy tells john dutton that his fingertips hurt even though he can't.

Spencer cannot be john's grandfather, the generations don't fit. We have been told the ranch is a 7th gen ranch and that the current john is a 5th gen montana rancher whose family was here 6 years before montana was a state. Spencer is a 2nd gen montana dutton. Any child spencer has will be a 3rd gen dutton while john's father has to be a 4th. The 1923 family tree suggests spencer and alex will become the parents of john dutton's father. Spencer is the younger son of james (tim mcgraw) and margaret dutton (faith hill) from the. He stays close to the ranch, helping jacob and cara build the family empire.

Played by brandon sklenar, spencer\u2019s adventures are a key plotline in 1923. Brandon sklenar casts doubt on spencer dutton's john family tree claims paramount+. Coming into 1923, many wanted to know which characters were the grandparents of kevin costner's john dutton. John's father, john dutton ii, was seen multiple times in yellowstone through flashbacks, but his parents were never revealed. A key detail on the show\u2019s imdb page lists a character as \u201cspencer 1969,\u201d confirming that spencer dutton not only survives the events of 1923, but also plays a crucial role in the future. This development suggests that spencer may even be the grandfather of john dutton, tying together multiple generations of the dutton family. He is also the sibling of john dutton sr (james badge dale), who met his end in an earlier episode.

1923 star brandon sklenar, who plays spencer dutton, many fans believe the show confirmed in the final episode that spencer dutton was the grandfather of john dutton iii. Since taylor sheridan hasn\u2019t been the best in continuity, fans feel like there was a huge mess up in this finale, given that it makes john dutton iii only a fourth. In 1923 season 2, the last two surviving family members that could feasibly serve as john dutton's grandparents are spencer dutton (brandon sklenar) and jack dutton (darren mann). The finale answers the great dutton mystery. Spencer is john dutton\u2019s (kevin costner) grandfather. It is unclear if john dutton iii is a direct descendant of spencer or not. See our full dutton family tree graphic to learn more about how the duttons are related.

The 1923 family tree hints that spencer and alex will become the parents of john dutton's father. Spencer is the younger son of james (tim mcgraw) and margaret dutton (faith hill) from the 1883 series. Why did the duttons need to wait for spencer to get back to defend the ranch from whitfield? What is going to happen to alex and spencer\u2019s baby\u2014who will become john dutton, grandfather to. There are two different ways to interpret spencer dutton's time jump in 1923 season 2's finale, and either scenario has massive ramifications. 1923 shocks audiences with its latest episode, which brutally kills off a major character without warning. What does his death mean for the finale?

The war for the yellowstone ignites in 1923 season 2's finale, and it's a bloodbath that results in casualties for the duttons and their enemies.